Long Island Exterminators

Mouse Control on Long Island

The first cold nights of fall, you hear something small running inside the wall behind the stove, and in the morning there are droppings in the silverware drawer. Cornell's IPM program says field mice move into buildings from fall through spring, and house mice can live their whole lives indoors.

Get mouse control quotes

No. 3House mouseMus musculus

Cornell’s IPM program names the common pest rodents in New York as the house mouse, the white-footed mouse, the deer mouse and the Norway rat. A&C Pest Management in East Meadow says the house mouse and the Norway rat are the rodents it sees most on Long Island. Whatever the species, the job is the same three parts: find how they get in, close it, and remove the ones already inside.

Mouse control prices from Long Island companies

ServicePriceSource
Initial rodent treatment (inspection, bait stations, sealing)$250 to $500Quest Pest Control, Feb 2024
Full exclusion, sealing entry points$400 to $1,500 or moreQuest Pest Control, Feb 2024
Quarterly monitoring$150 to $300 a visitQuest Pest Control, Feb 2024
Recurring plans with rodent serviceFrom $60, $90 or $150 a month, plus an initial feeA&C Pest Management, Oct 2026
Exclusion with an A&C planExtra charge, not in the monthly priceA&C Pest Management, Oct 2026
Mouse treatment, New York City$200 to $500 to start, then $100 to $175 a monthAdvanced Pest Management, 2026
Exclusion, New York CityAdds $500 to $2,000 or moreAdvanced Pest Management, 2026

The biggest swing in a mouse quote is whether sealing is included. Two prices that look far apart may simply be one with exclusion and one without, so ask.

House mouse or field mouse

Cornell describes the house mouse as an even grayish brown, 2.5 to 3.75 inches long, with a nearly bare tail about as long as its body. White-footed and deer mice are the same size but have white bellies. They spend most of their lives outdoors and come in from fall through spring. Cornell’s point about them is the useful one: if you find a white-bellied mouse inside, there is an opening somewhere that needs closing.

Closing the gaps is the real job

The Illinois Department of Public Health says a mouse can slip through a crack about the diameter of a pencil, slightly larger than 1/4 inch. Its sealing advice:

  • seal every opening larger than 1/4 inch
  • pack holes with steel wool mixed with caulk
  • use metal or concrete for foundation cracks and where pipes and wires come in
  • skip plastic sheeting, screen, wood and rubber, which mice chew through

The same guidance points to foundation cracks, utility openings and the edges of doors and windows as the places to look first. If mice have gnawed at a door edge, it says to cover it with metal.

Traps, bait stations and kids and pets

A&C Pest Management describes tamper-resistant bait stations secured to the ground, traps inside, and exclusion for an extra fee. The EPA’s rules of thumb for any household:

  • use only tamper-resistant bait stations for poison bait
  • put traps and stations where children and pets cannot reach them
  • follow the label on any rodent product

The Illinois health department adds that too few traps is a common mistake. Snap traps go along walls, behind objects and in dark corners, no more than 10 feet apart where mice are active. Bait may need to stay out for up to three weeks before feeding stops.

Questions for the mouse company

  • Is sealing included in this price? If not, what does it cost and what materials do you use?
  • How many follow-up visits are included?
  • Who checks the traps and removes dead mice? NYC’s health department guidance says dead-rodent pickup belongs in a written plan unless you agree otherwise.
  • Is this a one-time job or a monthly contract, and how do I cancel?
  • What is your NYSDEC business registration number? Check it on NYSPAD.

Cleaning up after mice

The Illinois health department says to wear rubber or plastic gloves when handling dead mice and to disinfect traps by soaking them in 3 tablespoons of bleach per gallon of water. Nests of shredded paper and a musky smell are the signs to look for when you clear out a cabinet or the back of a closet.

Exterminators to call about mice

Companies based in Nassau and Suffolk. Ratings are a Google Maps snapshot from October 2026, and the registration line shows whether we found the company in NYSDEC's records.

Mouse control questions

How much does an exterminator charge for mice on Long Island?

Quest Pest Control, serving Nassau, Suffolk and Queens, lists an initial rodent treatment at $250 to $500, covering inspection, bait stations and sealing, and full exclusion at $400 to $1,500 or more (February 2024). A&C Pest Management in East Meadow sells plans starting at $60, $90 and $150 a month plus an initial fee, with exclusion as an extra charge (October 2026).

Why do mice keep coming back after the exterminator?

Usually because the way in was never closed. The US EPA warns that mice caught and released can find their way back unless the entry points are sealed, and the Illinois Department of Public Health says to seal any opening larger than 1/4 inch.

Are bait stations safe with kids and pets?

The EPA says to use only tamper-resistant bait stations and to put traps and baits where children and pets cannot reach them. A&C Pest Management says it secures its stations to the ground.

Is it a mouse or a rat?

Look at the droppings. Cornell's IPM program puts mouse droppings at 1/8 to 1/4 inch long and Norway rat droppings at 3/4 to 1 inch.

Sources (7), checked October 2026
  1. Cornell IPM, Mouse and Rat Biology and Behavior
  2. Illinois Department of Public Health, House Mouse Prevention and Control
  3. US EPA, Options for Dealing With Rodent Infestations
  4. Quest Pest Control (a Rest Easy Pest Control brand, Nassau, Suffolk and Queens), Pest Control Cost Guide (Feb 15, 2024)
  5. A&C Pest Management (East Meadow and Islip), Rodent Control on Long Island (offers through Oct 31, 2026)
  6. Advanced Pest Management (Garden City and Glendale), How Much Does Pest Control Cost in NYC (Mar 2026, updated Jun 2026)
  7. NYC Department of Health, Selecting and Working with a Pest Management Professional
Get quotes